Jasmine green tea brewing with loose leaves beside a cup of strained tea and Garden Vigil.

Your Green Tea May Not Be Bitter. Your Water May Be Too Hot.

HOUSE LEDGER // 008

Some people decide they don't like green tea after one cup.

Too bitter. Too sharp. Too drying.

Sometimes the leaf is the problem. Sometimes it's the way the leaf met the water.

Green tea can be sensitive to temperature and time. Change either one and you change what the water draws from the leaf. Before deciding green tea simply isn't for you, it may be worth looking at how you brewed it.

BREWING IS EXTRACTION

The moment tea leaves meet water, extraction begins.

Water draws soluble compounds from the leaf. Together, they shape the aroma, body, sweetness, bitterness and astringency you experience in the cup.

Temperature changes how quickly and how much gets extracted.

Hotter water generally extracts more aggressively. Depending on the tea, that can bring forward characteristics you want. It can also make bitterness and astringency more prominent.

With green tea, more isn't always better.

The goal is to find balance.

BITTERNESS AND ASTRINGENCY ARE DIFFERENT

They're easy to confuse.

Bitterness is a taste.

Astringency is the drying, puckering sensation that can leave your mouth feeling rough after a sip.

Green tea can have both. Neither automatically means something went wrong. In balance, they can give a cup structure and complexity.

When they dominate, however, the quieter parts of the tea can become harder to appreciate.

So when someone says green tea tastes “too bitter,” the experience may actually be bitterness, excessive astringency, or some combination of the two.

Brewing can change that balance.

START WITH LESS HEAT

There isn't one correct temperature for every green tea.

The leaf itself matters. So do the amount of tea, water, steeping time and your own preference.

But boiling water doesn't have to be your starting point.

If a green tea repeatedly tastes harsher than you'd like, lower the temperature before writing off the leaf.

Then taste again.

That small adjustment can teach you more than memorizing a supposedly perfect number.

WHY GARDEN VIGIL STARTS AT 175°F

For Garden Vigil, our jasmine green tea, we begin at 175°F.

That's a starting point for this particular tea, not a rule for every green tea.

Use about 2.5 grams of tea per 12 ounces of water and steep for 4–6 minutes.

Then pay attention to the cup.

If you want to adjust it, change one variable at a time. A little more leaf. A little less time. A slight change in temperature.

That way, when the cup changes, you'll have some idea why.

Brewing instructions give you somewhere reliable to begin.

Your palate decides where you go from there.

TIME MATTERS TOO

Temperature doesn't work alone.

A lower brewing temperature doesn't mean the leaves should sit in the water indefinitely. Time continues to affect extraction.

If your green tea tastes more bitter or drying than you'd like, look at both the kettle and the clock.

You don't need to overhaul your entire method.

Change one thing.

Taste again.

STEEP IT AGAIN

One of the pleasures of loose-leaf tea happens after the first cup.

Use the leaves again.

The next infusion won't necessarily taste exactly like the first. Some characteristics may soften. Others may become easier to notice. With further infusions, the cup may become gentler as the leaves continue to give up what they hold.

There isn't a universal sequence every tea follows.

That's part of the reason to keep tasting.

The second cup isn't simply a repeat of the first.

It's another chance to see what the leaf has to give.

TRY IT YOURSELF

The easiest way to understand temperature is to taste what it changes.

Take the same green tea and prepare two small cups.

Keep the amount of tea, water and steeping time the same.

Use boiling water for one.

For the other, start around 175°F.

Taste them side by side.

Which seems more bitter?

Which feels more drying?

Where is the aroma clearer?

Do you notice sweetness in either cup?

Which one would you rather keep drinking?

You don't need sophisticated tasting vocabulary.

You're simply paying attention.

And once you taste the difference for yourself, a brewing temperature stops being an arbitrary number on a package.

It begins to make sense.

LET THE LEAF TEACH YOU

Good tea doesn't require laboratory precision.

It rewards attention.

Temperature. Time. Leaf. Water.

Change one thing and taste again.

If you've always thought green tea was bitter, give it another chance before deciding that's simply what green tea tastes like.

Use a little less heat.

Pay attention to the first infusion.

Then steep the leaves again.

You may find that the leaf had more to give than the first cup allowed.

— House Ledger // 008


FROM THE HOUSE LEDGER

This entry began as House Ledger // 008 — Your Green Tea May Not Be Bitter. Your Water May Be Too Hot. on Instagram.

The original carousel introduced the relationship between water temperature, steeping time and repeated infusions.

SOURCES & FURTHER READING

Saklar, S., Ertas, E., Ozdemir, I. S., & Karadeniz, B. (2015). Effects of different brewing conditions on catechin content and sensory acceptance in Turkish green tea infusions. Journal of Food Science and Technology, 52(10), 6639–6646.

Xu, Y-Q., Zhang, Y-N., Chen, J-X., Wang, F., Du, Q-Z., & Yin, J-F. (2018). Quantitative analyses of the bitterness and astringency of catechins from green tea. Food Chemistry, 258, 16–24.

Lee, J., Chambers, D. H., & Chambers, E. IV. (2013). Sensory and Instrumental Flavor Changes in Green Tea Brewed Multiple Times. Foods, 2(4), 554–571.

Back to The Scriptorium