Pour-over coffee brewing beside a clear carafe of water in warm morning light.

The Water Matters: Why Better Coffee Needs Better Water

You upgraded the coffee.

You found freshly roasted beans. You paid attention to the grind. Maybe you started weighing your coffee and water instead of measuring by eye.

Then you filled the kettle from the same faucet you always have.

That last ingredient deserves more attention.

Brewed coffee is overwhelmingly water, but water does more than fill the cup. Its mineral composition can influence extraction and, just as importantly, how acidity and other characteristics present themselves when you taste the finished coffee.

So when the same coffee tastes surprisingly different somewhere else, the brewer may not be the only explanation.

The water may have changed.

WATER IS AN INGREDIENT

We tend to think of water as neutral.

It isn't.

Drinking water can contain calcium, magnesium, sodium, bicarbonate and other dissolved substances. The amounts vary depending on the source and treatment of the water.

For coffee, two ideas are particularly useful to understand: hardness and alkalinity.

Hardness generally describes the amount of dissolved calcium and magnesium in the water.

Alkalinity describes the water's ability to buffer, or neutralize, acids. Bicarbonate is commonly responsible for much of that buffering capacity.

Those two characteristics can affect the cup in different ways.

You don't need to become a chemist to make better coffee.

But knowing they exist explains why simply asking whether water is “hard” or “soft” doesn't tell the whole story.

MINERALS AND EXTRACTION

When hot water meets ground coffee, hundreds of soluble compounds begin moving from the grounds into the brewing water.

The chemistry of that water matters.

Research by Christopher Hendon, Lesley Colonna-Dashwood and Maxwell Colonna-Dashwood examined how dissolved ions interact with compounds found in coffee. Their work showed that magnesium and calcium do not behave identically during extraction, helping establish why mineral composition deserves attention alongside familiar brewing variables such as grind, temperature and ratio.

That doesn't mean adding more minerals automatically makes better coffee.

There is a balance.

ALKALINITY CHANGES WHAT YOU TASTE

There is another part of the water conversation that often receives less attention: alkalinity.

Coffee naturally contains acids that contribute to its flavor. Bicarbonate in brewing water can buffer some of those acids.

Too much buffering can mute the lively acidity that makes certain coffees expressive.

Too little can allow acidity to present more sharply.

This is one reason two waters that both appear perfectly clean can still produce noticeably different cups.

AVOID THE EXTREMES

So what should you actually put in the kettle?

For everyday brewing, the principle is simpler than the chemistry:

Start with fresh, clean water that tastes good on its own and has some mineral content. Avoid extremes.

For most people, the practical question is simply whether their water is helping or getting in the way.

If your tap water has an obvious chlorine taste, strong mineral character or another unpleasant flavor, remember that those characteristics enter the brewer too.

Filtered water can be a useful place to start.

At the opposite extreme, don't assume that removing virtually everything from water automatically improves the cup. Brewing water and completely demineralized water are not the same thing.

Clean matters. Balance matters too.

THE EASIEST TEST REQUIRES NO EQUIPMENT

Before buying minerals, testing strips or another piece of coffee gear, run an experiment.

Brew your coffee twice.

Use the same coffee.
Same dose.
Same grind.
Same water temperature.
Same brewing method.

For one brew, use your usual water.

For the other, use a good-quality filtered water with some mineral content.

Then taste them side by side.

Don't begin by asking which one is technically correct.

Ask what changed.

Is one brighter? Sweeter? Flatter? More bitter?

Does one reveal an aroma you didn't notice in the other?

Does the finish linger differently?

You may notice very little. You may notice considerably more than expected.

Either result teaches you something about your water.

BETTER BEANS DESERVE BETTER WATER

Specialty coffee gives you more to work with.

Origin, variety, processing, roast development and brewing all contribute to what eventually reaches the cup. Water participates in that process every time you brew.

That doesn't mean you need perfect water.

It means water deserves the same intentionality you've already started giving the coffee.

Before changing the grinder again, buying another brewer or blaming the beans, consider the ingredient hiding in plain sight.

Same coffee.
Different water.
Different cup.

Taste the difference.

— House Ledger // 011

FURTHER READING & SOURCES

Hendon, C. H., Colonna-Dashwood, L. & Colonna-Dashwood, M. (2014). The Role of Dissolved Cations in Coffee Extraction. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 62(21), 4947–4950.

Specialty Coffee Association — Water and Coffee Acidity: How to Adapt Your Water for Different Extraction Methods.

FROM THE HOUSE LEDGER — Instagram

Back to The Scriptorium